In the event you’re a farmer who has one thing prospects need, it solely is sensible to do your greatest to get it to them. Until, after all, if it’s one thing that’s unlawful to promote in your state — one thing like uncooked butter, for instance.
That’s the dilemma that Billie Johnson, a dairy farmer in japanese Oregon, is going through. She says there are companies that wish to purchase her farm’s unpasteurized, uncooked butter, however as a result of Oregon doesn’t enable retail gross sales of uncooked butter, she’s needed to flip to politics searching for an answer.
For the second 12 months in a row, she has gone to the state Capitol in hopes of resolving this challenge This 12 months she’s pitching a plea for the passage of Home Invoice 2612, which might enable for the sale of butter constructed from milk that hasn’t been pasteurized. The invoice would additionally direct the state’s Agriculture Division to ascertain grades and requirements for such butter.
Supporters of the invoice say it should give new choices to dairy farmers and customers with out sacrificing meals security.
Violations of the laws can be punishable by as much as a 12 months in jail, a prison fantastic of as much as $6,250 and a civil penalty of as much as $10,000.
However that doesn’t scare Johnson, just because she believes that uncooked butter is protected. So protected, actually, that she calls it “mind meals.”
“I need anybody who needs it to have the ability to get it,” she mentioned. “I need to have the ability to promote it wherever within the state the place there’s a marketplace for it.”
“Now we have a variety of demand for uncooked butter,” she informed legislators throughout a latest listening to earlier than the Oregon Home Agricultural and Pure Assets Committee.
On the nationwide stage, the Meals and Drug Company has banned uncooked butter and different unpasteurized, uncooked dairy merchandise — besides aged cheese — from being transported or bought throughout state traces.
In feedback concerning the Oregon invoice, Lapsley McAfee of Uncooked Farm (initially Natural Pastures Dairy Firm) in California mentioned that in his state, uncooked butter is bought in 500 shops.
“It’s a high vendor,” he mentioned. Describing it as a low danger meals, he mentioned that it’s significantly safer than uncooked milk. Not solely that, he mentioned there have been no sicknesses related to it up to now 10 years in CDC’s database.
“All individuals ought to have the ability to benefit from the healthful advantages of uncooked butter,” he mentioned.
Mark McAfee, proprietor of Uncooked Farm, mentioned that his dairy can’t make sufficient unpasteurized butter to fulfill demand “at this level.” Up to now 20 years, it has bought greater than 2 million kilos of uncooked butter with none recognized incidents. But although he can legally promote his uncooked butter in California, he can not ship it out of state.
Whereas the retail sale of uncooked butter is prohibited in Oregon, it’s authorized in 11 states. And promoting it on to prospects is authorized in three states. Nevertheless, the Meals & Drug Company prohibits it from being bought throughout state traces.
“Companies are asking us for this product,” Johnson mentioned throughout a latest listening to earlier than the Home Agricultural and Pure Assets Committee.
The meals security debate
Whereas raw-butter customers and advocates give it an enthusiastic thumbs up, Tami Kerr, government director of The Oregon Dairy Farmers Affiliation, urged lawmakers to rigorously contemplate the oversight and regulation of merchandise similar to uncooked butter.
“If individuals get sick from it, it provides the trade a black eye,” she mentioned, referring to dairy typically. “And it’s not a lot a matter of if however when.”
“We perceive the need of some small producers and their markets to have entry to uncooked merchandise, together with butter,” she mentioned. “We additionally perceive the worth of pasteurization and combating micro-organisms in retail merchandise.”
These microorganisms embody E. coli, Listeria and Salmonella, foodborne organisms that may get individuals sick, very sick, and even kill them.
However to Johnson, offering uncooked milk and uncooked milk merchandise for individuals is all concerning the survival of the household farm. As a part of that, meals security is paramount.
“It’s a method of creating a approach to get what we produce on the farm on to customers,” she mentioned.
Saving the farm
Johnson’s farm, Windy Acres Dairy Farm (https://www.windyacresdairy.com) in Japanese Oregon, has 70 cows, though not all of them are milkers. The farm is a herd share, which signifies that members personal a part of it. In addition to uncooked butter, it produces uncooked milk, kefir, yogurt, cream and aged cheese — “something you’ll be able to consider that may be made with uncooked milk,” Johnson says.
Underneath a herdshare association, members don’t purchase any of the dairy’s merchandise as a result of they’re part-owners of it. It is a method that dairies can supply uncooked milk and different uncooked milk merchandise with out being underneath the state’s Agriculture Division’s laws. Some individuals name it a loophole that lets them get away with producing raw-milk merchandise which might be prohibited underneath state legislation. It additionally frees them from inspections.
However to Johnson and different raw-milk dairy producers, herd shares are a approach to keep in enterprise. And that’s the place uncooked butter comes into the image. Contemplating the sturdy demand for it, to have the ability to promote it to eating places, espresso retailers, grocery shops and different retailers would assist flush extra money into the dairy’s bottomline.
And persons are keen to pay a fairly penny for it: $16 a loaf. (A loaf is equal to a pound.)
“It’s all within the eyes of the beholder,” Johnson mentioned concerning the value of uncooked butter. “It you worth your well being, you’ll worth your meals.”
She additionally mentioned that it’s “actual meals” and has higher taste than the standard butter you purchase within the retailer.
Proponents say that the passage of HB 2612 would give dairy farmers a greater shot at making a residing and will assist stem the decline within the variety of Oregon dairy farms. In 1992 Oregon had 1,900 farms with dairy cows, in accordance with USDA information; the newest figures from the Oregon Dairy Farmers Affiliation reveals there are 194 dairy farms left within the state.
Johnson mentioned with the ability to purchase uncooked butter in shops would assist hold prospects from touring to northern California to purchase it. And that, in flip, would assist hold extra of the state’s meals {dollars} within the state.
If the invoice have been to be adopted, it could go into impact on the 91st day after the session has adjourned in June.
To follow the progress of this bill, click here.
(To join a free subscription to Meals Security Information, click here.)
